Skip to Content

Rebuke, indeed. But has the U.S. electoral map just had a long-lasting change?

There was a definite theme in the overnight headlines, as votes were counted in the U.S. midterm elections — and Democrats routed Republicans, seizing both the House (as expected) and, far more solidly than many pollsters suggested, the Senate.

The word “rebuke” was in one headline after another:

Polls had consistently been predicting a strong night for the Democrats, but the extent of that strength was dialled down, given how most pollsters had consistently underestimated Donald Trump and the GOP in the last three consecutive presidential cycles.

Midterms can be quite different from presidential years, and I suspect 2026 will be long studied. The demographic shifting was remarkable — but to what extent was this a protest vote, and to what extent is it a substantial remaking?

Republicans will definitely be among those asking such existential questions. Earlier this morning, Ron DeSantis, the Republican governor of Florida — a state where there were Democratic breakthroughs in Miami — wrote that his party “might not have a shot at Senate control until 2032.”

The electoral map sure does look different this morning. Maine flipping blue was not out of bounds (although how many articles were there about the Energizer bunny of political survival, now-defeated Republican Susan Collins), but there are some surprises, for sure. But Kansas? South Carolina? Iowa? As I write this, Mississippi is still undecided, and may go blue.

And then there’s Texas. From Noah Smith’s Noahpinion newsletter this morning:

And most of all, Texas is blue. Not just the Senate race, either — the GOP governor, Greg Abbott, has been unseated by Democratic challenger Gina Hinojosa. Bo French, who tweeted alarm at seeing Indian American football fans at a University of Texas game two months ago, lost his bid for Texas Railroad Commissioner to Democrat Jon Rosenthal. The fall of Red Texas is an epochal, era-defining event. Growing up in Texas, I saw Dems win statewide office occasionally, but these were always old-school conservative Southern Democrat types. Yesterday’s election saw Gina Hinojosa and James Talarico, both staunch progressives, win the governorship and one of the Senate seats. In fact, the only Republican now holding a statewide office is…Ted Cruz.

The phrase “Ted Cruz, Republican of Texas” has a more … singular meaning this morning.

The rebuke from the midterms will not stop Donald Trump from signing executive orders. But he no longer can rely on either compliance or silence from Congress. No one is expecting another impeachment campaign, but watch for the Democrats to hold him to account, and to make life very difficult for front-bench (and wildly divisive) allies like Pete Hegseth and Kash Patel.

More interesting will be how rank-and-file Republicans — what’s left of them, as so many old-school Reagan- and Bush-era types were bullied as “swamp” things and intimidated into silence — react when Trump starts swinging his bat.

For instance, how locked in step will Republicans be with Trump about Russia and Vladimir Putin?

It’s also likely that more GOP types will openly challenge Trump’s economic policies, including his tariffs on Canada. Writes John Paul Tasker this morning on CBC News:

I suspect that will start to change as Republican survivors of the blue tsunami look around and see just how many colleagues who remained loyal to Trump lost their races tonight. As Trump’s influence fades, we could start to see more Republicans break with him on important policy matters, joining those who vocally opposed Trump’s trade war with Canada during this midterm election. 

I imagine the knives will be out, too. It was curious that the first thing Donald Trump blamed on election night was Fox News, of all things. So far, as that CNN link shows, Republicans have been loath to blame Trump himself.

There’s a lot of dust to settle yet, and the new Congress won’t be able to do anything tangible until January.

But the lay of the land is dramatically different in Washington this morning.

Share this post


Follow Me on Substack