Skip to Content

Nigella Lawson hit the nail on the head about ‘naughty’ foods

“I don’t approve of talking about food as naughty. We need to take our pleasures where we can in life.”
— Nigella Lawson

The latest season of the Great British Bake Off (renamed the Great British Baking Show in North America) has not yet aired in Canada, but a comment earlier this fall from new judge Nigella Lawson has been reverberating online.

When longtime judge Paul Hollywood remarked that a cookie (well, biscuit, to be exact; this is after all the British Bake Off ) should be indulgent and naughty, Lawson was quick to reply with the words above.

Lawson was talking about a whole lot more than a mere cookie.

Her comment also addresses a fairly rampant assumption that foods now have moral values. Some are virtuous, sure, but much more often we hear about the other side: it’s sinful, and not just in a delicious way, it seems.

Our social media feeds are filled with influencers who scream (sometimes shirtless in supermarkets) about “toxic” foods, tell you to never eat specific foods, and cast aspersions on consumers who do. (The fact that many of them sell supplements is not lost on me here.)

The world of nutrition is much more complex than all of that, and labelling our food with virtues and vices can lead us down some terrible paths, not the least of which involves disordered eating.

It also jumbles our thinking about food. Like a lot of people, I’ve had a complex relationship with eating and weight over the years, and I was struck by Lawson’s defence of enjoying food for what it is, and parking the descriptors.

Without having seen the whole episode yet (we’re Bake Off fans), I don’t know the full context, and I know what Paul Hollywood was getting at with an adjective like “indulgent.”

But it was the other word — “naughty” — that Lawson seized upon, and I think rightly. “Naughty,” even if meant innocently, brings some baggage to it.

Eating a variety of foods and paying attention to nutrition requires effort. But it shouldn’t also mean sacrificing pleasure altogether, and enjoying food as more than just fuel.

Here’s a meme I enjoyed seeing in my Instagram feed this fall, from the Dutch-British illustrator Marloes De Vries.

You know a comment is resonating with people when it gets turned into memes and cartoons.


Share this post


Follow Me on Substack